Saturday, October 26, 2013

A reflection on my experiences of culture and identity in relation to education


Growing up in a regional town in New South Wales, I attended one of three local high schools. Looking back now I can see how the school cultures and dominant ideologies influenced both my behaviour and the behaviour of others’.

Looking at the school on a macro level, there was very much a culture of ‘not caring’ about school. Whilst students who performed well at school weren’t necessarily outcasts, the rebellious students were often seen as the ‘cool’ kids, while those who were more academic were labelled ‘squares’.

I found this interesting as I grew up and mixed with friends from different schooling backgrounds, particularly those who attended private schools. In their cases, it seemed to have been much more acceptable to do well at school.

From my studies in education thus far, I have learned that SES background can have a tremendous influence on a student’s academic outcomes. Perhaps because my school had a large proportion of low SES students, the dominant culture was to not care about education.

For me, coming from a higher SES background compared to many students at my school, as well as coming from a family that encouraged education, I managed to see past this culture and focus on achieving – for the most part.

On a more micro level, it is interesting to look back at the significant influence the local Italian culture played in shaping my identity.
Our local community had a large population of Southern Italian immigrants and a majority of my close friends shared this heritage.

In many circumstances, I actually felt that my Anglo Saxon Australian culture was lacking, while my Italian friends seemed much more ‘cultural’ with their interesting cuisine and family traditions. Like Anne Phillips (2006) writes, culture has a tendency to be associated with non-Western or minority cultural groups. (p. 5) In other words, these students and friends and their families all seemed so much more ‘cultural’ than me and my ‘Aussie’ family – ‘skips’ as my Italian friends used to say.

This influence of Italian culture was only heightened further once I started a relationship with an Italian boy, which lasted for the greater part of my high school years. Strangely, Italian culture became the dominant culture in my world, and I wanted to do as much as I could to fit in. As Wadham, Pudsey and Boyd (2007) write, being raised in a particular culture encourages us to believe certain things about the world. I began to think like my Italian friends. Most notably, in my Southern Italian friends’ and boyfriend’s worlds, girls obeyed males, and I allowed myself to be seriously influenced and controlled by my high school boyfriend.

I relate strongly to Anne Phillip’s (2006) concerns about the dangers of exaggerating the significance of culture and its hold over people’s actions. I allowed my boyfriend at the time to control me and behave in a way I now see as very unfair, because I excused it as part of his culture, as the way he had grown up and the way his father, uncles and grandfather had all demonstrated to him throughout his childhood and adolescence. Even though he would apologise for this, he would blame his culture, and say it couldn’t be helped.

Thankfully, at the end of high school, the ideas and beliefs that my family had raised me with outshone those of my boyfriend, and I went off to university as a young, independent girl, who could achieve anything, as my parents had always told me – not the good little housewife my boyfriend briefly had me wanting to be.

References:

Phillips, A. (2006). What is Culture? In Arneil, Barbara and Deveaux, Monique and Dhamoon, Rita and Eisenberg, Avigail (eds) Sexual justice/ cultural justice. London, UK: Routledge, 2006, pp. 15-29.

Wadham, B. Pudsey, J. & Boyd, R. (2007). Culture and education. Sydney, Pearson Education

No comments:

Post a Comment